Blog · Funding

Startup Financing with VCs: Legal Due Diligence Preparation

Funding

Just like we wouldn’t buy a pig in a poke, investors don’t give money to startups without thoroughly vetting them first. In this blog post, we look at how startups can prepare for legal due diligence by investors and which questions they should already address in the pitch deck.

Beyond the business case and the team behind the startup, investors are interested in answers to the following legal questions:

Which regulations affect the startup and how do they influence or restrict the business case?

From data retention requirements to workplace standards — government regulators are often creative when it comes to regulating different industries. Regulations often bring nothing more than added overhead and costs for startups, but in some cases they can render the entire business model obsolete, for example through high barriers to market entry.

If your startup is operating in heavily regulated sectors such as finance or healthcare, intensive research should be conducted so that regulatory questions can be addressed directly with investors.

What is the IP / intellectual property of the company and how is it protected?

Investors are strongly interested in companies with sustainable competitive advantages. If entry barriers — particularly intellectual property — are absent or low, competitors have an easy time copying the idea. This hurts not only profit but also the value of the shares.

If the business model is built on intellectual property, founders should ensure they know what types of IP their company owns (e.g. patents, copyrights, domains, data, designs, trademarks, etc.), how it is or can be protected, and whether others have already protected the same IP.

How are the company shares divided among founders and why were they divided this way?

Particularly in the early stages, VCs invest largely in the team rather than the business idea itself. The departure of an important team member or disputes among co-founders is one of the most common reasons startups fail. This is why VCs scrutinize potential investments for long-term team engagement and stability. In the shareholder structure, there are two particular “red flags”:

  1. One founder has a small stake: If, for example, the brilliant CTO only has a few percent because they joined the team later, there’s a good chance they won’t stay long-term.

  2. All founders have equal stakes: Equal division among founders can be a sign that they simply avoided the difficult discussion about who contributes more value to the company. When this discussion isn’t held early, it often leads to major conflicts later.

Before an investor’s money is transferred to the company bank account, additional legal matters must be clarified. In addition to negotiating all legal documents that belong to a financing round, a legal due diligence takes place beforehand. This is a legal review of the company to ensure there are no hidden legal risks. Typically, investors distinguish between smaller “curable” legal problems and larger “incurable” ones (so-called ‘deal killers’).

Depending on the investor’s risk tolerance, the company’s stage, and the investment amount, the due diligence review is more or less intensive. The following LEXR C-RICH model offers an optimal guide for the legal review of a company:

2.1. C – Corporate / Company Law

  • Share distribution: Who currently owns shares? Are there outstanding agreements for issuing new shares (e.g. from a previous convertible loan)? Is there an employee share plan in the form of shares or phantom shares? What transfer restrictions exist (e.g. in a shareholders’ agreement)?

  • Share transfer: Have all previous share transfers been executed and documented correctly (written assignment)?

2.2. R – Regulatory

  • Does the company hold all required licenses?

  • Are social insurance, pension plans, and tax matters properly set up? In particular, employee share plans can create tax liabilities.

  • Are minimum applicable data protection regulations being met?

2.3. I – Intellectual Property

  • Is intellectual property adequately protected?

  • Is all intellectual property owned by the company? (In particular, intellectual property created by co-founders before incorporation is often not properly transferred to the company.)

  • Are there competing IP rights, for example in the form of patent applications in current or potentially future markets?

2.4. C – Contracts

  • Are there major contract risks in critical agreements (e.g. with a university in the case of a spin-off)? Risks include early termination rights, purchase options, or burdensome patent prosecution obligations.

  • Is there a solid template for customer contracts that is consistently used with all customers?

2.5. H – HR / Human Resources

  • Are there written and complete agreements with all employees and freelancers, and does the company correctly distinguish between these two forms? Background: In particular, intellectual property must be assigned to the company, even for freelancers. Notice periods for non-essential employees should not be too long, as this can create significant costs in the event of restructuring. Engaging people as freelancers who are actually employees can also be a costly mistake.

  • Are there former employees who could have claims against the company? For example, former co-founders who still have claims on the company’s intellectual property or shares.

In addition to our C-Rich model, the due diligence checklist from SICTIC is a good resource that also covers non-legal aspects of due diligence for startups.

3. Summary

Legal preparation for a financing round is not rocket science but hard work that must be done carefully to improve a startup’s chances of securing funding. Due diligence ranges from preparing a pitch deck where obvious legal questions are thoroughly addressed to ensuring all legal foundations of the company are solid before the investor search begins.

Book a non-binding discovery call